What we said: "In its desperation to be edgy and in-your-face, this sequel sometimes falls just as flat as its predecessor, the copious neon pink daubings incapable of concealing its bland, repetitive wasteland and elevate this open-world shooter above its siblings of a similar ilk. Nicfaz keeps it nice and simple, meanwhile. "I was thrilled that I was able to get the ending I was aiming for." "Spiders best yet," says jbumi in what may be damnation with faint praise. But the elements that matter have been imbued with such love and care - so much so that I quickly forgave this ambitious RPG its shortcomings." What we said: "GreedFall has more than its fair share of faults, and its curious mix of the sweet and the sour is far from a roleplaying revelation. "One of the best racers of the generation," says kalel-ofkrypton, "and reminiscent of the favoured racers of previous gens." Looks amazing, handles like a dream, excellent AI opponents, great post release support, a tuning system that makes sense and a physics system that feels like it needed next generation power to make possible." Which is all well and good, but they go on to diss Fast & Furious and I'M NOT HAVING THAT. "More fun than Forza and Gran Turismo and makes every everything Codemasters turn out look pish. "Best racing game in years," writes merf. Unassuming it may be, but it's also absolutely wonderful, a knockabout racer that sticks to what Bugbear does best this is all about cars lunching one another in a variety of events that are tuned towards maximum carnage, and as ever there's a cathartic joy to be found in seeing fields of pre-loved machinery crumble at your fingertips." What we said: "A simple no-frills game that's more Destruction Derby than Flatout, evoking a different era for the racing genre with its no-nonsense approach. Although I'm not quite sure about your take on Fallen Order. Thank you all for your contributions, and for proving once again you've all got better taste in gaming than us. 2019 is nearly done, and to put a ribbon on it all we present to you the Eurogamer reader's top 50 games of the year.